The Definition Disclaimer

posted Apr 28, 2012
in Bloviation

Human words are a great deal fuzzier than the concepts they hope to cover. For instance, consider the word "love"; it means anything from stalker-level obsession to a moderate preferance ("I love pizza!"). In order to talk about anything precisely it is often necessary to specify what a given word refers to in some specific context.

Every writer has the right to choose what definitions they are using in a particular bit of text. If they say that they have chosen a particular definition of "love", that is not a point that can be usefully debated. Definitions are neither right nor wrong. They are only useful or not useful. What can be debated is statement the word is used to make.

In principle, one could have two people debating with each other, each choosing a very different definition of love. There is nothing wrong or illogical about this, except that it may be confusing.

This is my generic disclaimer I offer when choosing a definition:


Site Links


All Posts